Saturday, March 28, 2009

Turn off the mains today


There is an excitement building up as the Earth Hour 2009 approaches. More people aware. More people talking AND planning action this time. And for a change, this does not involve celebrities or reality shows!

As one billion citizens of Planet Earth switch off the power for an hour, it will mean so many gigawatts of power saved, and hence the many tons of carbon emissions put off for an hour.

How did this happen? Through a combination of media coverage and social norms.

We have known since some time about what is happening to our climate and planet. But even the educated among us have not bothered to act, whether it be in the way we use power at work and homes or in the way we travel. We have chosen to believe that governments have to do something about it, not us. We have chosen to believe that our individual actions are no big deal, ‘when my neighbour does not change’!

Why? Is it because we believe we are safe? Or that we don’t care for the next generations? Is it a question of our priorities – today over tomorrow? Or is it because we can’t see the result of our actions immediately – good or bad?

In his book, Fostering Sustainable Behaviour: Community-based Social Marketing, Canadian environmental psychologist Doug McKenzie-Mohr talks of people’s inaction during energy-conservation campaigns and traces it to various reasons like wanting to see clear immediate indications that what they're doing matters. This is unfortunately not going to happen.

There is need to move from scaring to showing the way how individuals can reduce their personal footprint. Experts believe why this has also failed is because of ‘single action bias’ where most prefer to do one thing instead of the more familiar ‘10 things to do’ to reduce your carbon print! This is where social norms play a big role. Humans love to conform. It makes us feel secure to stay in line.
Wesley Schultz, a California-based environmental psychologist who specializes in social norms, used "normative messaging" to try to get people to lower their home energy use. Simply giving households regular feedback on how they were doing relative to the rest of the group, along with a little social approval or disapproval of their consumption, was enough to get virtually everyone to cut down on their energy use.

The peer grading did the job! The comfort that one is not alone comes as a booster to take action on something as ‘elitist’ as climate change.
Social psychologists are trying to pressure governments and policymakers to stop thinking about financial incentives and information campaigns and start thinking about norms.

Now imagine, what can be achieved if earthlings fixed an Earth Hour every month, on their own. (Not thanks to Bescoms!) Or even better, if all of us would simply learn to switch off all devices when not in use. Or look at ways we can cut our energy use, without ‘sacrificing’ comforts! Or take a bus when available. Or walk a little a bit more to the stores instead of driivng. How many Earth Hours can we cook up? Innumerable.

As we struggle to bring down emissions, collective inidvidual actions can have a cascading effect. Let us do our bit from today.

Happy Earth Hour with friends and family.

Wednesday, March 25, 2009

First game lost

Two essential ways to address a problem, one is look at symptoms and treat them and the other to look at the root cause and address that. So also in climate change. We can either look at ways in which to cut our emissions or seek ways to offset the change by geo-engineering the ecosystem.

The recent Indo-German experiment Lohafex sought to fertilise the ocean with iron oxides which could lead to increased algal growth which could then absorb the carbon dioxide. The verdict so far is one of failure.

In the experiment, researchers fertilized a 300 square kilometer patch of the ocean, which saw a burst of algal growth. For long-term sequestration to work, enough of that algae would have to sink to the bottom of the ocean.

However, within two weeks the algae were being eaten by copepods, which then were eaten by amphipods. The result being that far less carbon dioxide made its way to the sea floor than had been anticipated.

The next step would be to see how to keep the copepods away!! Which could well present yet another problem to which we respond with yet another experiment from the labs.

An unending quest as we struggle to understand the complex eco-biosystem that sustains life on earth.

Would it not be much easier to look at ways we can cut our emissions?

Tuesday, March 24, 2009

India joins Irena

India joined the International Renewable Energy Agency last week, becoming the largest energy consumer in the recently launched organization. "The fact that India, the world's most populated country after China, joined - it signals that large developing countries are taking this issue seriously," said Daphne Wysham, a fellow at the Washington, D.C-based Institute for Policy Studies. "The rest of the world should take notice."

Critics in the United States have questioned whether IRENA could in fact help India expand its renewable energy capacity. "Experience proves that such agencies almost always quickly become bureaucracies that are effective only at perpetuating themselves and that often become obstacles to progress," said Myron Ebell, director of energy and global warming policy at the conservative Competitive Enterprise Institute, in an e-mail.

Rather than create an institution with permanent positions, Ebell said that ad-hoc international collaborations such as the Asia-Pacific Partnership have proven useful in exchanging clean energy technologies. Herman Scheer, a Social Democratic member of the German Parliament and chair of the World Council for Renewable Energy, has led IRENA's development since 1990.

IRENA's opponents in the United States have questioned the need for an additional bureaucratic institution when organizations within the United Nations and the International Energy Agency already focus on developing renewable energy.

Scheer responded that these organizations have not devoted sufficient resources or expertise to expanding renewable energy capacity, noting that a separate institution would ensure that clean energy receives additional support at a time when investments are growing.

Are we doing enough? Will joining such agencies help?

Good or bad?

And while on Nano, how about looking at the pros and cons. One, it is cheap, small, gives good mileage and good emission standards. It is a better alternative to the millions of Indians who commute by two-wheelers. It is affordable, safe transport!

So why are environmentalists dubbing it a nightmare? Simply because of the numbers. At least 25 percent of the 50 million who use two-wheelers are expected to shift. As disclosed by the company, the bookings are expected to exceed records and random lots will be resorted to, to allocate the cars. As more and more people buy the cars, the emissions will multiply, however low they are for a single car.

And then, imagine the traffic jams and the idling it will cause? And not to forget the demand on energy, i.e petrol.

News reports say Nano potentially could expand the country's auto market by 65 percent and spur a 20 percent increase in auto sales in its first year. Honda, Toyota and Fiat too are developing competitors to the Nano.

India is the world's fourth-largest overall producer of the greenhouse gas and its carbon emissions are expected to triple by 2020, according to the United Nations. A car like Nano will affect climate projections drastically, say experts.

Tata claims that the Nano is cleaner than the scooters it will replace and claims the car's catalytic converter cuts emissions by 80 percent. The Nano supposedly emits 30 grams of carbon dioxide per kilometer, well below the 160 g/km average of Europe's cars and far less than the 130 g/km standard the European Union will adopt in 2012. Even if half a million Nano's hit the road and each of them travels 5,000 miles a year, they will be responsible for less than 8 percent of India's annual CO2 emissions.

On the energy side, the International Energy Agency has said "alarming" growth in worldwide energy needs could, among other things, bring worldwide shortages. It said India's motor vehicle fuel consumption will triple by 2030.

What when the prices go up again as we said in our earlier post? Will a few more million cars on the roads spell trouble? Or do we look at the new Nano as the way out of the squeeze, small and efficient? As the rich west continues to opt for big SUVs, can it afford to point fingers at the new kid on the block?

Share your views.

The next big hump coming soon


Tata’s Nano couldn’t have timed it better. According to a report on oil prices, it is time to think small, especially when it comes to cars.

The new report from the McKinsey Global Institute, called Averting the Next Energy Crisis: The Demand Shock, that considers a global economic recovery in2010, warns of another oil-price shock between 2010 and 2013. Prices will rise above $100 a barrel.

The energy demand that has stagnated during the recession will pick up and while the supplies of coal and gas ‘appear to be plentiful enough’ to prevent long-term price inflation, McKinsey expects demand for oil to outpace supply.

Energy demand, it says, will grow by 2.3% per annum from 2010 to 2020 even if, as expected, energy consumption in the U.S. and Japan remains virtually flat. Especially in developing markets, where carbon dioxide emissions will also grow by 2 percent mostly thanks to the growth in air transport, steel and petrochemicals. Much of this will be from China and India.

Among the suggestions it makes are, removal of subsidies that keep oil prices low in places like Saudi Arabia, Iran and Venezuela; improving efficiency of cars and trucks, more flexi-fuel cars, etc.

Nano could be your answer?? Or better still, a truly effective public transport system?

Monday, March 23, 2009

Underplaying again

Leading scientists from the Tyndall Centre for Climate Change Research say that the level of carbon budgets for the UK, recommended by the Committee on Climate Change (CCC) last December were too weak to limit the temperature rise to 2C and stop dangerous climate change.
At the Copenhagen meet, Tyndall center scientists claimed that the Committee’s report was based on “naively” optimistic” assumptions and scenarios. The report recommends a 34% cut by 2020 but the scientists stress that a minimum reduction of 42% must be made through cuts in the UK, rather than buying offsets abroad.

The committee’s report is “inevitably and significantly compromised” because it focuses on limiting temperature rise to 2C above pre-industrial levels, which the EU defines as dangerous. The report claimed that GHGs would peak at 2016, while the Tyndall centre feels a realistic target is 2020. But this could be too late for the 2C target.

This comes in a week, which has seen Shell announce that it will pull out of renewable energy projects due to their weak economics, and the closure of the Low Carbon Buildings Programme by the government.

However, things seem to be going as planned on the UK’s first national emissions trading scheme - the Carbon Reduction Commitment (CRC). Details were announced this week. The Scheme that covers the non-energy intensive sector is expected to reduce over 4MtCO2 per year by 2020.

Under-estimation, under-valuation, non-action continue to play big roles as the earth seems headed to a dangerously tipping point from where there may be no coming back. Despite clinching evidence, why are we more keen on fudging figures and buying time than cutting down on our consumption or changing to alternatives?

What does it take to shake a lethargic world community into action – fast and unprecedented?

Pricing it right

EDF of France and E.ON of Germany, two of the most high-profile nuclear supporters, said attempts to reach 35% of electricity generated by renewables is not only unrealistic but also damaging to alternative schemes such as nuclear plants.

“The deployment of high levels of intermittent renewables for electricity generation will require the construction of additional carbon-emitting plant as back-up for when renewables are not available to meet demand,” EDF argued. “This is likely to be predominantly gas-fired and will therefore undermine efforts to reduce dependence on non-domestic fuel sources.”

“A 25% electricity target will provide the best platform for further decarbonisation of electricity generation in the period beyond 2020, through a combination of further renewables, new nuclear and coal and gas with carbon capture and storage.”

The energy demands require a mix of all sources. The question boils down to how to put renewables on an equal footing without appearing to handicap any. Let it to the market, or ensure that the price of all electricity includes all negative impacts through their entire life cycle? Be it wind, coal or nuclear. Will that be enough?