Friday, January 30, 2009

Here and Now

In its report Pathway to a Low Carbon Economy, McKinsey&Company has emphasized the urgency to act now and to act collectively. While there is immense potential to avert the 2 deg rise in temperature, it also cautions that ‘not only will all regions and sectors have to realise the full potential for abatement, it will not do to have deep emission cuts in a few alone.’

Total worldwide cost annually will be 200-350 billion euros. High, but ‘within long term capacity of financial banks’ and made good by energy savings down the years.

The analysis finds that ‘there is potential to reduce GHG emissions in 2030 by 35 percent compared with 1990 levels, or by 70 percent compared with the levels we would see in 2030 if the world collectively made little attempt to curb current and future emissions. This would be sufficient to have a good chance of holding global warming below the 2 degrees Celsius threshold, according to the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change.’

While the report also mentions a high cost technical path as well as one borne out of a behavioural change, the focus is on technical abatement costing a lesser 60 euros per tonne of carbon dioxide. These will not cause a material effect on lifestyles (which it acknowledges as tough to expect. Another topic for the blog another day!)

By capturing all the abatements across all sectors starting 2010, the emissions in 2030 will be 35-40 percent lower than in the reference year 1990. These will be the emissions one can expect if peaking happens around 480 ppm. Good enough.

But as the study notes, this will call for change on a huge scale. Like avoiding till 2030 deforestation of around 170 m hectares as also new forests on 330 m hectares! Like ensuring low carbon power generation should rise to 70 percent of global electricity. Tough, but feasible with ‘concerted global action’.

Action must be timely. A 10 year period will not equip against the 2 deg rise warned by IPCC. By delaying action even by a year, an abatement of 1.8 gigatonnes of carbon dioxide equivalent is lost.

Four categories for abatement opportunities are highlighted: efficiency, low carbon energy supply, terrestrial carbon and behavioural change. But the last is only qualitatively analysed and not quantitatively.

Regarding forestation, as more than 90 percent of the potential is in developing nations with insatiable thirst for industrialization, it becomes a challenge. This is why it advocates linking the abatement to the development agenda. Similarly, to push efficiency it calls for technical norms and standards; long term incentives to push renewable energy; and support for emerging technologies.

Do you believe global collective action will be forthcoming? Will the change happen? If so, when? Most of us resist change, and when it brings along tough choices, the tendency is to put it off that much more. How do we get our governments to change their ways of thinking?

Come on, let us have your thoughts.

Thursday, January 29, 2009

Agency for renewable energy

The first multinational agency focused solely on popularizing and adoption of clean energy across the globe was launched this week. Called the International Renewable Energy Agency (IRENA), the agency will help governments and private industry to expand renewable energy installments throughout the industrialized world, where investments are already on the rise, while also assist the developing world acquire the expertise to establish its own clean energy industries.

Naturally, this will be a big help for developing nations, especially in terms of technological know-how transfer. It will be interesting to see what mechanism IRENA evolves.

More than 120 delegates attended the IRENA founding conference in Bonn on Monday, and 75 nations signed the agency's treaty. Originally the initiative of Germany, Spain, and Denmark, IRENA now includes countries such as France, India, the United Arab Emirates (UAE), and Kenya. The founding treaty becomes effective once it is ratified by 25 countries.

Although the global credit crunch has slowed many renewable energy investments, wind, solar, and geothermal industries expanded worldwide last year. About 12,000 megawatts of wind power capacity were installed in 2008 alone, bringing the global total to 106,100 megawatts, according to the World Wind Energy Association. In addition, 9,740 megawatts of cumulative solar photovoltaic (PV) systems and at least 6,000 megawatts of geothermal energy projects have been installed, according to the Worldwatch Institute and U.N. Environment Programme, respectively.

Do we need such agencies? Are these mere clean energy jingoisms? Or will they be able to give wings to a renewable sector witnessing slump in the recession? What do you think? We would love to hear.

Wednesday, January 28, 2009

Energy economy

In one of his recent addresses after becoming president, Obama declared that, ‘No single issue is as fundamental to our future as energy!’ That is what we believe too. How are we addressing the challenge? Are we taking up enough measures?

A look at Obama’s ‘bold action’ to create a new American energy economy could be worth it. The American Recovery and Reinvestment Plan is expected to put 460,000 Americans to work, with clean energy investments and double the capacity to generate alternative energy over the next three years. Double renewable energy in three years. Isn’t that worth following?

New fuel standards to reduce dependency on foreign oil which mean a 40 percent increase in fuel efficiency is expected to save 2 million barrels of oil daily!

He went on to call for a global coalition to ‘protect our climate and our collective security. I've made it clear that we will act, but so too must the world.’ And that's how Obama plans to ‘ensure that nations like China and India are doing their part, just as we are now willing to do ours.’

Clearly, there is hint of ratifying Kyoto protocol if India and China go along. Will they? Should they? What do you think?

What recovery plan does India have?

Dire Straits

Going with the present trend, greenhouse gas levels around the mid-century will produce devastating long-term droughts and a sea-level rise that will persist for 1,000 years. This is regardless of how well the world curbs future emissions of carbon dioxide. Just in case you decided that we might as well continue with business as usual, from here on things are set to get worse.

Climate researchers from the U.S. National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, Switzerland and France said their analysis shows that carbon dioxide will remain near peak levels in the atmosphere much longer than other greenhouse gases.

At the moment, carbon concentrations in the atmosphere stand at 385 parts per million. While the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change has set a goal of stabilizing atmospheric carbon at 450 ppm, the way we are putting out emissions place projections at 550 ppm by 2035, and then rising after that point by 4.5 percent a year.

If carbon dioxide concentrations peak at 600 ppm, several regions of the world like southwestern North America, the Mediterranean and southern Africa will face major droughts as bad or worse than the Dust Bowl of the 1930s. Global sea levels will rise by about three feet by the year 3000. This does not factor in melting glaciers and polar ice sheets, which would add more to the sea level rise.

For the sub-tropics, a drop in precipitation by 10 percent could result even with carbon levels at 450 ppm. Big droughts will follow.

In the last five years, emissions have continued to grow despite warnings. Notably the west continues in its path while new entrant China has just beaten the US.

So what do we do? Blame each other? Ask the 'original perpetrators' to pay up? Does the planet care where the emissions come from?

Ocean's Twenty

The German government has given the go-ahead for the Indo-German scientific project LOHAFEX that saw environmental concern over geo-engineering. The reviews concluded that there were no ‘scientific or legal objections’ to the spreading of 20 tons of iron sulfate on ocean waters.

The director of the Alfred Wegener Institute said that the experiment was to understand the role of iron in climate system. He said it was not a geo-engineering option of sequestering carbon dioxide into the waters. The team has started discharging the solution into the water.

The question we would like to ask is: are scientific and legal objections alone to be considered? How inclusive of ecological considerations is our scientific view? Science has been largely viewed as a force unto itself with its sole mandate to find the truth. But when the means involves invasive methods, how benign is it?

Do we really know what 20 tons of iron sulfate across a 300 square kilometer patch in the South Atlantic ocean could mean to marine life? Perhaps the Indian team from National Institute of Oceanography can explain. The explosion of plant life, mainly planktons, that would suck in the carbon dioxide is unquestionably ocean-engineering. Could someone explain how it is not?

Meanwhile, a study on geo-engineering says, ocean fertilization options are “only worthwhile if sustained on a millennial timescale and phosphorus addition probably has greater long-term potential” than either iron or nitrogen”. Can the planet take all those experiments of different groups?

The study looks at ideas like sun shades in the sky, aerosol spraying, etc and concludes that if present trends continue, by 2050, only stratospheric aerosol injections or sunshades in space have the potential to cool the climate back toward its pre-industrial state.

Costs will be high and it is best to avoid adding to the problem instead of looking at ways to doctor ecosphere. Unless we mend our ways drsatically, we will need to do some altering our environment.

What are your views? Is that a better idea? Instead of giving up on those 'dreams of a luxurious life, is it better to change the planet?

Friday, January 23, 2009

Customer makes the choice

Things are looking up in the US for renewable energy, according to the latest figures from the U.S. Energy Information Administration. The agency just released “Electric Power Industry 2007: Year in Review,” and for the first time, renewables (not including hydro-electric power) led the way in new electric generation capacity in the U.S.

Wind accounted for more than half of the new added capacity.

However, carbon dioxide emissions by electric generators and combined heat and power facilities increased by 2.3 percent in 2007, to 2.52 billion metric tons, up from 2.460 billion. That reverses a decline in CO2 emissions reported for 2006.

But the EIA report isn’t all about utility-scale power. The report also talks about some new experiments like homes feeding small scale renewable energy into the grid. With net metering, people get paid for electricity they feed into the grid. In the US during last year, there were over 40,000 people taking part in this experiment. In yet another ‘green pricing program’ users, both residential and industrial, bought green power from their utility.

Isn’t that a good way of encouraging green power? But if the prices are costlier than regular grid power, how many ‘conscientious’ buyers will the scheme see in a price conscious place? Maybe tagging along an incentive will help? Anyone out there with customer experiences care to tell us what you think?

Thursday, January 22, 2009

Hope in the air

In what is now the talk of the globe - yes, the Obama speech - if there is one phrase that could sum up the essence of that well-thought out, comprehensive and restrained address, it is the call for ‘a new foundation for growth’.

In all that he spoke, the American economy, foreign affairs or global warming, the new US president Barack Obama set a new line of thought going. On rolling ‘back the spectre of global warming’ and restoring ‘science to its rightful place’… and wielding technology's wonders to raise health care's quality and lower its cost, it was a new foundation.

Especially in the field of energy, the address saw him talk of harnessing ‘the sun and the winds and the soil to fuel our cars and run our factories.’

Obama has earlier too called for an effort to overhaul US energy policy on the scale of the Apollo . His plan includes unleashing 150 billion dollars over 10 years to create five million new green jobs, an 80-percent reduction of greenhouse gas emissions by 2050 and ensuring that 10 percent of US energy consumed comes from renewable sources by 2012 and 25 percent by 2025.

Obama's stimulus plan revealed last week called for doubling the production of renewable energy in three years. It envisages energy-efficient retrofits for 75% of government office buildings, and weather-proofing for two million homes.

At an Ohio factory that makes components for wind turbines, he said, "A renewable energy economy isn't some pie-in-the-sky, far-off future…it’s happening all across America right now. It's providing alternatives to foreign oil now. It can create millions of additional jobs and entire new industries if we act right now."

But the task of convincing Congress to pass a law restricting emissions will be difficult. Especially to negotiate a specific target and reach a full and final agreement in the few months before Copenhagen may be tough. Experts are suggesting an intermediary agreement that talks of a post 2012 framework, but not specific commitments from each country.

This is important because developing nations like India and China that have not ratified Kyoto protocol will act according to what the US does.

But Obama also said 'we will not apologize for our way of life'! even if he added '…each day brings further evidence that the ways we use energy strengthen our adversaries and threaten our planet…'

Again a message in that? And if the Americans will not change their way of life, why should the aspiring developing world not aim for that?

Either way, the world will be watching Obama closely. Perhaps new foundations for growth will spring up in more than the US.